Consensus vs Elicit
Consensus and Elicit sit in the same category and share 2 tasks. The verdict below is calculated for each role from the tasks, the role fit and the price.
Short answer
Consensus wins for 10 of 20 roles in our data. Consensus starts at $8.99/mo and Elicit at $12/mo on the cheapest paid plan.
Verdict by role
| Role | Better choice | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Accountant | Elicit | covers 1 of this role's tasks against 0 |
| Lawyer | Elicit | covers 1 of this role's tasks against 0 |
| HR manager | Consensus | cheaper entry plan |
| Finance manager | Elicit | built for this role |
| Manager | Consensus | built for this role; cheaper entry plan |
| Marketer | Consensus | built for this role; cheaper entry plan |
| Sales manager | Consensus | built for this role; cheaper entry plan |
| Data analyst | Elicit | part of the role's core toolkit; built for this role |
| Teacher | Consensus | built for this role; cheaper entry plan |
| Executive assistant | Consensus | built for this role; cheaper entry plan |
| Logistics manager | Consensus | built for this role; cheaper entry plan |
| Procurement manager | Elicit | built for this role |
| Secretary | Consensus | built for this role; cheaper entry plan |
| Recruiter | Either one | even on tasks, Consensus is cheaper to start |
| HR administrator | Elicit | higher total score on tasks and fit |
| Tax consultant | Elicit | covers 1 of this role's tasks against 0 |
| Auditor | Elicit | covers 1 of this role's tasks against 0 |
| Economist | Elicit | built for this role |
| Project manager | Consensus | built for this role; cheaper entry plan |
| Social media manager | Consensus | built for this role; cheaper entry plan |
Side by side
| Consensus | Elicit | |
|---|---|---|
| Vendor | Consensus | Elicit |
| Category | Research and search | Research and search |
| Free plan | Yes: Unlimited search, a limited number of AI summary queries a month | Yes: A limited number of credits for search and data extraction, limited upload of your own PDFs |
| Cheapest paid plan | Premium, $8.99/mo | Plus, $12/mo |
| Top plan | Teams, $9.99/mo | Pro, $49/mo |
| Tasks covered | 3 | 3 |
Consensus: Answers from research papers with a meter of how many studies agree and disagree.
Elicit: Research paper search that extracts data into a table with the columns you define.
Tasks both handle
Only Consensus covers
Only Elicit covers
Pitfalls to watch at work
Consensus
- The agreement meter counts papers without weighing their quality: one large study matters more than ten small ones
- For decisions about people (hiring, evaluation) a research summary stays background information and is never the basis for the decision
Elicit
- The model extracts data from papers and makes mistakes in numbers: open the paper at the cited page before quoting
- Coverage of non-English publications is thin, so on questions of national law and accounting the service has little to say
FAQ
Is Consensus or Elicit better for work?
In our data Consensus is the better choice for 10 of 20 roles. The table above shows the reason for each role.
Which is cheaper, Consensus or Elicit?
Consensus starts at $8.99/mo and Elicit at $12/mo on the cheapest paid plan.
Do Consensus and Elicit have free plans?
Consensus: Yes. Unlimited search, a limited number of AI summary queries a month. Elicit: Yes. A limited number of credits for search and data extraction, limited upload of your own PDFs.
Compare Consensus with
- Consensus vs ChatGPT
- Consensus vs Perplexity
- Consensus vs Semantic Scholar
- Consensus vs Scite
- Consensus vs Gemini in Google Drive
Compare Elicit with
Alternatives to Consensus · Alternatives to Elicit · Consensus pricing · Elicit pricing
AI tools weekly for your role
One email a week: new tools, price changes and one tested prompt for your job. Free, unsubscribe in one click.